Viewers React to ‘Yellowstone’ Season 5 Episode 12: ‘So Upset with Tonight’s Episode’

A shocking horse-related death in “Yellowstone” stuns fans, igniting debates about the show’s daring twists and sudden losses of beloved fan-favorite characters.

Fans of “Yellowstone” were left reeling after Season 5, Episode 12 delivered one of the series’ most heartbreaking moments. The episode centered on the sudden, tragic death of Colby, a beloved ranch hand played by Denim Richards, sparking an outpouring of emotions on social media.

The dramatic moment unfolded as Carter, a young member of the Dutton Ranch team, attempted to handle a volatile horse nicknamed “Maneater.” While trying to refill the animal’s water trough, Carter was attacked, leaving his face bloodied.

Colby rushed to intervene, stepping into the danger zone to protect the teen. Tragically, Maneater trampled Colby before delivering a fatal kick to his chest, leaving fans devastated by the cowboy’s sudden and heroic death. “So upset with tonight’s episode 😭 why Colby!” one viewer exclaimed.

Another expressed their frustration, “Wow, not Colby! I’m so fed up rn 😂[sic].” The emotional weight of Colby’s death resonated deeply, with one fan remarking, “That hurt worse than Johns [sic].” Someone else typed, “Can’t believe Colby is gone.”

Meanwhile, others commented on the rapid losses of the show’s roster including Kevin Costner’s John Dutton III, “Characters dropping like flies after John Dutton exited.”

More viewers took to social media to express a range of strong emotions following Colby’s unexpected death. One described the event as unnecessary.

One viewer shared their surprise at Colby’s death, noting ranch hand Teeter’s emotional reaction and admitting it was difficult not to cry. The comment also conveyed bittersweet anticipation for the remaining episodes of the season.

Colby’s tragic fate followed Episode 11, which featured the violent death of Sarah Atwood, a longtime adversary of the Dutton family.

Episode 11 revealed Sarah’s downfall after her plot to assassinate John was uncovered by Beth and Kayce. Outmaneuvered, Sarah faced betrayal from her own hired hitman, who turned on her to avoid exposure once John’s death was officially ruled a homicide.